Yesterday I wrote about how Ed Sheeran stopped using his phone back in 2015. There’s a second half to that story he told at the concert.
A few years ago, Ed was sued over “Thinking Out Loud.” The family of Marvin Gaye’s co-writer accused him of copying the feel of an old hit – “Let’s Get It On.” He talked about what it’s like to live through something like that said something true about court cases. You lose when you lose, and you also lose when you win, because of everything the fight takes out of you along the way. His ran for the better part of a decade.
He decided to fight it because the claim was that he’d copied a chord progression. And you cannot own a chord progression. They’re the building blocks of songs, used in hundreds of them, free for everyone to reach for. It mattered so much to him that he said he’d have walked away from music for good if he’d lost. And, to make his point, he played many songs before and after “Let’s Get It On” that all use the same chord to the grand jury (and won).
Here’s where the phone story comes full circle. As part of the case, he had to dig out that 2015 phone and switch it back on for discovery. Waiting inside were messages from a friend who has since died, arguments with an ex, conversations with family he’s no longer close to. A lot of old baggage that him all at once.
Out of that came a song, “Old Phone.” Writing it was how he closed the chapter, and then he put the phone away again.
He ended the story with a beautiful note about making music about a bad memory. When you go through something hard, creating a song about the experience means you’re able to walk away with gratitude.
This applies well beyond making music of course.
We don’t choose bad situations. But if we find the learning in it, we’ve made the best of it.
I found my old phone today
So full of love, yet so full of hate
I put it back inside there from whence it came
Nothing good will come from regretting
Conversations with my dead friends
Messages from all my exes
I kinda think that this was best left
There in the past, where it belongs
I feel an overwhelming sadness
Of all the friends I do not have left
Seeing how my family has fractured
Growin’ up and movin’ on




